Paradoxical emboli are proposed to occur when emboli that arise in the venous circulation, for example, from a deep vein thrombus, cross into the arterial circulation through a patent foramen ovale (PFO) or atrial septal defect, or through a pulmonary arteriovenous malformation (PAVM). Paradoxical embolism can be quite difficult to diagnose, and it is usually presumed, rather than confirmed, based on visualizing a right to left communication and/or shunt. PFO is common in the general population, present in about 20% of people. An association between PFO and ischemic stroke was first reported in younger patients (<55 years),
32 but the association has also been reported in older adults more recently.
33,34,35,36,37 However, while case-control studies report a positive association between PFO and cryptogenic ischemic stroke (odds ratio [OR] 3.12; 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.98 to 5.10),
35 two prospective cohort studies have failed to demonstrate an independent association between PFO and an increased risk of stroke, after a mean follow-up of 5 years
38 and 7 years.
39 In addition, studies have failed to show that the presence of an isolated PFO is a risk factor for recurrent ischemic stroke. Diagnostic investigations include transthoracic echocardiogram, transesophageal echocardiogram (TEE), and transcranial Doppler with contrast.
40 TEE is the gold standard investigation for diagnosis of PFO and estimation of PFO size, with a specificity and sensitivity of 100% for color Doppler TEE and 100% and 89%, respectively, for contrast TEE.
41 The optimal management strategy for patients with PFO and cryptogenic ischemic stroke remains controversial, due to difficulties in establishing a true causal relationship between PFO and ischemic stroke and a lack of randomized controlled trials delineating the best treatment options.
42 Although some studies have suggested an adjunct role for thrombophilic disorders,
42,43,44,45 the role for thrombophilic testing also remains uncertain. In healthy individuals with PFO, primary prevention with antithrombotic therapy is not currently recommended. The American Stroke Association/American Heart Association (ASA/AHA) currently recommends antiplatelet therapy for patients with ischemic stroke or TIA and a PFO to prevent a recurrent event (class IIa, level B evidence). There are no randomized controlled trials comparing oral anticoagulation to antiplatelet therapy, other than a subgroup analysis of the WARSS trial, which did not find a difference in recurrence stroke rates between treatment groups. An emerging management approach has been PFO closure, which may be achieved by transcatheter device closure, percutaneous device-less closure, and surgical closure by open or thoracoscopic access.
47 However, the recently presented CLOSURE trial did not report a benefit from PFO closure in approximately 900 participants after ischemic stroke, who were randomized to receive PFO closure or usual medical care, but did report an associated increased risk of new AF in the closure group on follow-up.
48 Other randomized controlled trials, evaluating other approaches to PFO closure following ischemic stroke, are ongoing. Management challenges are faced in patients with large PFO, PFO associated with atrial septal aneurysm
33,49 or in younger patients with no other risk factor for ischemic stroke, especially in those who experience a recurrent episode of ischemic stroke despite antiplatelet therapy.
An atrial septal aneurysm is a protrusion of part of the atrial septum through the fossa ovalis into the right or left atrium or both,
50,51 TEE is considered to be the investigation of choice for detection of atrial septal aneurysm.
52 An atrial septal aneurysm is associated with an increased risk of ischemic stroke, especially in association with a PFO. A meta-analysis of case-control studies comparing patients with ischemic stroke to controls reported ORs of 1.83 for PFO, 2.35 for atrial septal aneurysm, and 4.96 for both PFO and atrial septal aneurysm, indicating a greater risk of stroke from the combination compared to either condition alone.
53 Other potential explanations for the increased risk of stroke associated with atrial septal aneurysm include a predisposition toward atrial arrhythmias, thrombus formation, and left atrial dysfunction.
51,54,55,56
PAVMs, which are commonly congenital in origin, are abnormal connections between pulmonary arteries and veins. They are also associated with an increased risk of ischemic stroke,
57 and paradoxical embolism is considered to be the most likely underlying mechanism.
58 The reported incidence of stroke in studies of patients with PAVM has ranged from 2.6% to 25%.
59,60,61,62,63 The gold standard for diagnosis of PAVM is pulmonary angiography, although less invasive techniques such as contrast and helical CT, magnetic resonance angiograms, and contrast echocardiography are also useful.
64 Treatment is recommended for patients with PAVMs who are symptomatic or who have feeding vessel diameters >3 mm. Embolotherapy is the current treatment of choice for PAVMs. Surgical resection is reserved for those who fail to respond to, or are unsuitable for, embolotherapy.
65