The Obesity Encounter

The Obesity Encounter

Robert F. Kushner


Obesity is one of the most common medical conditions seen in primary care that affects nearly 40% of adults and 18% of children and adolescents.1 Obesity affects every organ system and is linked to the most prevalent and costly medical problems seen in daily practice. However, despite its high occurrence rate, associated medical problems, and impact on daily functioning and quality of life, patients infrequently present to the healthcare team with “obesity” as their chief concern. For this reason, it commonly falls on the healthcare professional (HCP) to proactively broach the subject of weight management even if the patient does not raise the subject. Depending upon the patient’s readiness to address his or her weight, the HCP needs to be able conduct a thorough assessment that includes taking a comprehensive history, performing a physical examination, and ordering pertinent laboratory diagnostic tests. This information is then assimilated to develop a personalized treatment plan. This chapter will focus on the elements of the clinical encounter that encompass a comprehensive obesity-focused assessment.


Patients seldom present to healthcare providers with “obesity” as their chief concern. Therefore, it is incumbent upon the healthcare provider to proactively broach the topic if excess weight or obesity is considered a significant contributor to the patients’ overall health. However, there are often competing barriers and demands that preclude raising the topic of obesity. Lack of time and more important issues/concerns to discuss during the clinical encounter are the two most common reasons HCPs may not institute a discussion about weight with their patients.9 This is a dilemma since compelling data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) show that patients whose weight problem was diagnosed and who were told of their weight status by their HCP were significantly more likely to perceive themselves as overweight, attempt to lose weight,10 and report a 5% weight loss over the year.11

There is no clearly established method for raising the topic of weight with patients; however, due to its sensitivity, words matter (Table 2.2). The approach HCPs use to broach this potentially sensitive topic may influence how patients react emotionally and cognitively to the discussion and advice provided.12 Language used by the provider sets the stage for the interaction. The reason for this concern is that the word “obesity” is a highly charged, emotive term. It has a significant pejorative meaning for many patients, leaving them feeling judged and blamed when labeled as such. This is not the case when patients are told that they have other chronic diseases such as diabetes or hypertension. Patients prefer that clinicians use more neutral words such as “weight, excess weight, BMI, or unhealthy weight” compared with more stigmatizing terms such as “obesity, morbid obesity, or fatness.” Asking permission to have the discussion is recommended as the first “A” in a modified 5 A’s framework for counseling that is directed toward obesity (the 5 A’s framework is discussed in more detail in Chapter 7).


Taking an Obesity-Focused History

Similar to any other presenting problem, the “history of present illness” (HPI) is an important and required section of the medical history when evaluating obesity as a distinct medical problem. The HPI includes the following:

  • The changes in health that led the patient to seek medical attention, including a clear, chronological explanation of the patient’s symptoms.

  • Information relevant to the chief complaint, including answers to questions of what, when, how, where, which, who, and why.

  • Information that informs the provider on the sequential development of the underlying pathologic process.

However, providers have not traditionally learned how to conduct an obesity-focused HPI. The two overarching features of an obesity history are to take a life course perspective and a patient-centered approach. The life
course perspective suggests that various biological, psychosocial, and cognitive factors throughout life influence health and disease risk.13 This perspective is consistent with the complex nature of obesity. Patientcentered approach is defined as “providing care that is respectful of and responsive to individual patient preferences, needs, and values and ensuring that patient values guide all clinical decisions.”14 Information from the history should address the following six general questions:

  • 1. What factors contribute to the patient’s obesity?

  • 2. How is the obesity affecting the patient’s health?

  • 3. What is the patient’s level of risk regarding obesity?

  • 4. What are the patient’s goals and expectations?

  • 5. Is the patient motivated and engaged to enter a weight management program?

  • 6. What kind of help does the patient need and want?

Weight History

Many of the elements of an obesity-focused history are included in an expanded social history that includes diet, physical activity, sleep habits, stress, etc. and the Review of Systems section. However, the skill of how to obtain a weight history and how to use it in developing individualized care plans is generally new to providers. The mnemonic “OPQRST” is commonly used for ascertaining the patient’s chief complaint and HPI and can be adapted for taking a weight history. The mnemonic stands for onset, precipitating events, quality of life/health, remedy, setting, and temporal pattern.15 Examples of questions that can be used to explore these features are provided in Table 2.3.

These six probing areas provide a contextual understanding of how and when patients gained weight, what management efforts were employed, and the impact of body weight on their health. The mnemonic is not intended to be used in a prespecified order of questions, rather it was developed as a technique to prompt recall of important information to cover during the history. A more efficient method to obtain much of this information is to ask patients to complete a previsit questionnaire that can be reviewed during the encounter. An example of a self-completed questionnaire is shown in Figure 2.2. From a practical point of view, a questionnaire can be given to patients at the end of a routine visit to be completed at home in anticipation of a return visit where obesity will be the central focus of the
encounter. Having patients reflect on these issues will save time and facilitate a more productive and therapeutic patient visit.

An additional technique is to ask patients to graph their weight changes over time, inserting life events or treatments that they feel were temporally related to weight changes16 (Figure 2.3). Patients are then asked to reflect on and discuss their weight journey. This activity allows patients an opportunity to express any underlying burden, frustration, struggle, stigma, or shame that may have been associated with trying to manage body weight. Similar to the previsit questionnaire, this exercise is most useful if accomplished ahead of a visit that is dedicated to obesity care. If the weight history is conducted properly, patients will feel validated and acknowledged regarding their weight journey, while the clinician should feel more empathetic and informed to provide meaningful and practical patient-centered treatment.

Medication History

A thorough medication history should always be taken to uncover possible drug-induced weight gain as well as for medications interfering with weight loss. This is called iatrogenic weight gain. Table 2.4 provides a list of medications that are associated with a gain of body fat. Medications should always be considered when there is a change in the trajectory of body weight coincident with starting a new drug. The most common offenders are neuroleptics, antidiabetic agents, steroids, and antidepressants.17 A list of medications that promote weight gain along with alternatives is also shown in Chapter 8 on Pharmacotherapy.

Taking a Comprehensive Social History

In addition to obtaining a weight history, other elements of the social history that are important for understanding the cause of weight gain include diet, physical activity, sleep patterns, and stress. This information can be largely obtained by using a standard patient questionnaire that assesses social determinants of health related to weight or by conducting a structured patient interview. More in-depth information about diet and physical activity will be covered in Chapters 5 and 6.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Jun 23, 2022 | Posted by in ENDOCRINOLOGY | Comments Off on The Obesity Encounter
Premium Wordpress Themes by UFO Themes