Overview of the Mental Health Section

Overview of the Mental Health Section


The mental health of immigrants has, as in the field of medicine generally, been relegated to secondary status as the acuity of physical and social needs predominates. It is only later, usually in resettlement, that the immigrants’ psychiatric and mental illness needs receive attention. Unfortunately, these needs are often ignored. Partly, this may be due to the chronicity and interrelationship of mental illness and integration or adjustment problems and the concomitant challenges to treatment. It is a testament to the insight of the primary editors of this text that mental health is given considerable priority as a part of immigrant medicine.


This section is intended to be pragmatic and practical but based upon findings in the published literature. The intended audience is primary care practitioners in resettlement countries such as the United States, but the principles should be relevant for social workers, psychiatrists, psychologists, and other mental health professionals, and students in the primary care and mental health professions. In addition, those who work for both governmental and nongovernmental agencies, especially in reception programs, may find this section helpful. Recommended resources for additional information are listed at the end of this overview.


A number of themes and commonalities are noted throughout these chapters, regardless of context, demographics, or time factors. Among them are: (1) the prevalence of major depression and PTSD across gender, age, and ethnic groups; (2) the interrelationship of not only the individual, but also family and community; (3) the interconnection of physical, psychiatric, psychological, and social problems; (4) the central role of culture and problems with equivalence (in concepts, language, metrics, norms) which interfere with the integration of immigrants into their host societies; and (5) the persistent role of trauma and violence history in precipitating long-lasting problems with mental illness and adjustment.


The mental health section includes three chapters which discuss epidemiology and risk factors, screening in primary care settings, and mental illness diagnosis and treatment. Eisenman discusses how to approach the identification of mental health problems and a history of torture in clinical settings where these are often missed. Specific instruments are identified for use in screening. In the chapter by Kinzie et al., the focus is on mental illness in immigrants, in particular major depression and PTSD. Case examples are used extensively to illustrate issues in diagnosis and treatment.


After these overview chapters, three chapters discuss populations selected for particular emphasis. Wenzel et al. discuss survivors of torture. This topic is particularly pertinent with recent debate over the definition of torture and whether its use can ever be morally justified, such as to prevent terrorist attacks. Torture victims have many of the same mental illness and social integration problems as refugees who have been traumatized in other ways, but the very personal nature of torture requires especially sensitive approaches to interviewing and treatment. Most of the authors in the mental health section, not only in this chapter, have worked with both traumatized refugees and specifically with torture survivors, illustrating the importance of this subpopulation. Ekblad et al. discuss interpersonal violence towards women, finding that it leads to more health and mental health problems and poorer integration into host societies. Ellis and Betancourt discuss children and adolescents, who have many of the same mental health problems and integration issues as adults, but require special approaches. Treatment ideally occurs in pediatric clinics or in schools. Another population, which is not discussed in a separate chapter, is the elderly. Although elderly immigrants deserve consideration as a special population, very little has been written about them.1 Those older than 60 years comprise up to 30% of the refugees in some United Nations camps. They may be unable to meet their basic needs because of physical disability, mental impairment, loss of social support, or malnutrition.2 Medications for chronic diseases may not be available. Access to health services may be difficult when mobility is limited. Losses after displacement can be more profound, and readjustment challenging, when the elderly have fewer future opportunities for rebuilding their lives. Carlin3 identifies problem areas for the elderly refugee or immigrant, including: (1) separation from or loss of family members, including disapproval by younger family members who are better able to acculturate, have no time to help, and have greater authority; (2) isolation from friends and problems making new friends; (3) compromised independence because of language difficulties and illness; and (4) loss of job status and productivity with few opportunities left. Interventions should take advantage of the respected position that the elderly have in many societies and cultures, such as in conflict resolution and as heads of extended families. Training for new vocations and skills should not be restricted to the younger members of society: the elderly have much to offer.39


Mental health and integration are difficult for immigrants and complicated for their providers. Despite these challenges, caring for immigrants is interesting and rewarding. It is important to adopt an integrated approach to mental healthcare that moves away from just psychiatric care. Even more than for the mainstream population, the responsibility for helping the troubled immigrant falls onto primary care.


Aug 11, 2016 | Posted by in INFECTIOUS DISEASE | Comments Off on Overview of the Mental Health Section

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access