Palliative Care into Practice


Symptom

Cancer (%) [16, 19]

Non-cancer (%) [18]

Cancer, AIDS, COPD, heart and renal disease (%) [17]

Fatigue

72–74

76

32–90

Pain

71–74

67

34–96

Lack of energy

69
  
Weakness

60
  
Appetite loss

53–70

55
 
Breathlessness

36

36

60–95

Anxiety/depression

40

57
 


First, recognize the presence of each symptom, then proceed to:



  • Establish its intensity, temporal pattern, any exacerbating/relieving factors, location, and effect on function and cognition.


  • Determine whether the symptom is acute, chronic or intermittent.


  • Identify any associated symptoms.


  • Assess its impact on quality of life, ADLs, cognition, decisional capacity, sleep, mood, and dignity.


  • Review previous and current treatment for the symptom.


  • Perform an appropriate, timely, and symptom focused physical exam.


  • Ascertain if possible, the likely pathophysiology underlying the symptom.


  • Consider whether any medication could be causing or aggravating the symptom.


  • Identify potentially reversible causes.


  • If necessary, use the least invasive diagnostic testing, if any, to minimize patient pain, discomfort, or suffering.


  • Given the above steps determine the most likely diagnosis, (if possible).


  • Always evaluate for the presence of any psycho-emotional, spiritual, social, or practical factors to the symptom.


  • Initiate palliative and traditional treatment based upon the primary illness, phase of illness, prognosis, comorbidities, patient/family preferences for care, and care setting.


  • Consider complementary and alternative therapies especially if requested by patients and families.

Any symptom c an be complex and multifaceted, thus an interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary approach, and treatment plan is more likely to be successful. Foremost, consider nonpharmacologic and practical interventions in an attempt to alleviate each symptom, i.e., change in body position, room temperature or ventilation, patient/family and staff education. Then consider pharmacologic interventions to primarily palliate each symptom. Finally, consider medical and/or pharmacologic treatments directed at the underlying cause of the symptom (if known). Response to the treatment and its outcomes, benefits, and burdens must be carefully monitored with the treatment adjusted accordingly, acknowledging that the goals of care can change over time where advanced care planning transitions to terminal care planning.

Keep in mind that interventions to relieve distressful symptoms can lead to unintended consequences (concept of double effect). For example the use of opioids to treat pain can result in constipation and/ or nausea, which in turn will require treatment. In such a situation, it is reasonable to continue the first treatment while initiating another treatment to alleviate its adverse effects. In the rare case of severe and intractable symptoms, including intolerable existential or psychological distress, the use of palliative sedation may be a consideration (NHPCO Position Statement 2010).

At the practitioner and systems level, use of unidimensional or multidimensional tools may be helpful to assess a variety of symptoms (refer to Table 2) dependent upon ease of use and evidence-based palliative care. The Edmonton Symptom Assessment Survey (ESAS) is a scale that assesses for the presence and intensity of multiple symptoms.


Table 2
Symptom assessment scales











































Symptom

Assessment scales to consider

Anorexia

Functional Assessment Anorexia/Cachexia Therapy Scale

Anxiety

Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale (HAM-A)

Cognition

Folstein MMSE, COGNISTAT

Constipation

Modified Constipation Assessment Scale, Patient Assessment of Constipation tool

Delirium

Confusion Assessment Method (CAM), Delirium Rating Scale

Depression

Beck Depression Inventory, Short Form Geriatric Depression Scale, Zung Depression Scale, Cornell Scale for Depression in Dementia, CES-D Boston Short Form

Dyspnea

Numerical Analog Scale (i.e., 0–10), Visual Analog Scale (VAS)

Fatigue

NAS, VAS, Fatigue Symptom Inventory

Nausea

VAS

Pain

Numerical Analog Scales (NAS), Visual Analog Scales (VAS), Verbal Descriptive Scale, Wong-Baker FACES Scale, FLACC Scale, Brief Pain Inventory (BPI)

Spiritual pain

FICA spiritual assessment tool, Herth hope index


Resources

City of Hope Pain and Palliative Care Resource Center. http.//www.​cityofhope.​org/​prc

UNIPAC Series. American Academy of Hospice and Palliative Medicine, 4th edn. 2012

Several reviews have more thoroughly detailed the management of pain and other symptoms that occur in patients with advanced illness who reside in long-term care facilities [5, 6] and in general practice [7]. Other excellent resources include the “UNIPAC” Series, a publication of the American Academy of Hospice and Palliative Medicine [8], Fast Facts and Concepts (available at the Center to Advance Palliative Care website), the American Medical Directors Association Clinical Practice Guideline (CPG) on “Pain Management in the Long-Term Care Setting” [9] and its respective CPG implementation manual, ePOCRATES Online [10], and ref. [11].

It should be noted that many medications used to palliate distressful symptoms are not FDA-approved for the treatment of these symptoms.


Anorexia


Anorexia is defined as a loss of appetite that may be associated with cachexia, the latter a catabolic state characterized by severe weight loss. Either may occur in the late stages of any severe progressive illness.

Management of anorexia includes the following:



  • Assess anorexigenic effects of medications such as chemotherapy, antidepressants, NSAIDs, opioids.


  • Evaluate whether it could be caused by or related to other symptoms such as nausea, constipation, or pain.


  • Assess for any potentially reversible medical condition such as rectal fecal impaction, urinary retention, oral candidiasis or other treatable causes such as GER, gastritis, or gastroparesis.


  • Initiate practical interventions: small, frequent meals; administer medications separate from or with meals; encourage good mouth care; try a variety of foods; improve the social and environmental aspects of eating.

Consider treating the primary symptom (i.e., anorexia) with an appetite stimulant such as:



  • A corticosteroid: prednisone 5–20 mg/day; dexamethasone 4–8 mg/day.


  • A progestin: megestrol 400–800 mg/day (trial 4–8 weeks).


  • If anorexia is concomitant with depression, it may be reasonable to prescribe mirtazapine as an appetite stimulant and mood enhancer that can also improve sleep.

Note that the appetite stimulant effect of corticosteroids often decrease after several weeks. Megestrol is associated with lower limb edema and an increased risk of thromboembolism. Consider oral nutritional supplements, though subsequent decreased intake at meals can occur as a result of their use. Giving smaller amounts of a high Calorie supplement throughout the day, with medication administration, may result in less decrease of intake at meals. If used, it is preferable to use nutritional supplements that are lactose free, especially in the elderly or African Americans who have a higher prevalence of lactose intolerance. There is insufficient evidence to recommend the use of cannabinoids (dronabinol), cyproheptadine, an androgenic steroid (oxandrolone) or thalidomide, though a therapeutic trial may be worthwhile in refractory anorexia. A patient’s advance directive for health care may either request or preclude artificially administered nutrition and hydration.


Dyspnea


Dyspnea is defined as discomfort in breathing that includes the sensation of breathlessness, shortness of breath or an increased work of breathing. Often it is not associated with tachypnea or hypoxemia. Its management includes the following:



  • Initiate practical interventions such as the use of a fan, ensure a comfortable ambient room temperature, eliminate respiratory irritants, reposition the person, encourage purse-lip breathing.


  • Assess for potentially reversible causes: pneumonia, pleural effusion, pulmonary embolus, heart failure, anemia, bronchospasm.


  • Identify any associated symptoms such as aspiration, excessive respiratory secretions, anxiety, social or financial problems, and spiritual suffering.


  • First-line pharmacotherapy for palliation of dyspnea is an opioid administered every 3–4 h. For mild dyspnea and to minimize the risk of respiratory depression in an opioid-naïve patient, start with morphine sulfate 2.5–5 mg PO or the oral morphine equivalent (OME) of another opioid, (refer to OME interconversion Table 12 later in this chapter). Titrate the opioid dose upward 25–50 % every 12–24 h to attain sufficient relief of dyspnea. Note that an opioid-tolerant patient is one who has been taking a daily oral morphine equivalent dose of 60 mg or more for 7–10 days.


  • Optimize medical treatment of the primary respiratory or cardiac condition (i.e., COPD, heart failure).


  • Consider addition of a low dose benzodiazepine for breakthrough or refractory dyspnea as anxiety can be a contributing factor.


  • Consider other medical treatments based upon their benefits and burdens, phase of illness, patient preferences, and advance health care directives.


  • Remember that patients with dyspnea often do better with a scheduled dose of an opioid (and a benzodiazepine) rather than as needed (PRN) dosing. Opioids are effective in treating dyspnea in patients with COPD, though may be less effective in patients with cancer or heart failure. There is poor evidence as to the effectiveness of nebulized opioids, though it may warrant a therapeutic trial in refractory dyspnea. Though the use of oxygen may reverse hypoxemia, dyspnea may not improve. Be aware of the potential for oxygen therapy to cause hypercapnia and subsequent obtundation or respiratory arrest. When using an opioid for dyspnea it is prudent to aim for a respiratory rate between 14 and 20.


  • Initiation or continuation of noninvasive ventilatory support (e.g., CPAP, BiPAP) may be warranted in special circumstances such as late stage COPD or ALS.

Not infrequently a family member may request the use of oxygen for non-hypoxemic dyspnea. While there is no evidence to support this, many times it may alleviate the discomfort of breathing that patients may feel as well as the emotional distress that families may experience when observing their dyspneic family member.


Nausea and Vomiting


The most rational approach to managing nausea and/or vomiting is to understand the four main pathophysiologic mechanisms and the neurotransmitters that mediate the emetic reflex in the brain (refer to Table 3). This will allow for a more rational and effective choice of antiemetic drugs (i.e., antihistaminic, anticholinergic, antiserotinergic, or antidopaminergic).


Table 3
Major mechanisms of nausea/vomiting
































































Cause

Pharmacologic management

Cortical:
 

• Tumor, increased intracranial pressure

Dexamethasone

• Anxiety, situational stressors

Benzodiazepine

• Pain response

Opioid, other pain medication/adjuvants

Vestibular:
 
 
Meclizine
 
Scopolamine
 
Dimenhydrinate

Chemoreceptor trigger zone:
 

• Medications

Decrease dose or discontinue, if possible

• Metabolic (e.g., kidney/liver failure)

Haloperidol, olanzapine

• Hyponatremia

Sodium chloride, demeclocycline

• Hypercalcemia

Bisphosphonate, dexamethasone

Gastrointestinal:
 

• Drug related

Stop drug, consider PPI

• Tumor

Promethazine, metoclopramide, octreotide

• Constipation

Bowel regimen

• Cough-induced

Opioid, anticholinergic


Adapted from UNIPAC Four, 4th edn., 2012, AAHPM

Management of nausea/vomiting includes:



  • Determine whether any medications are emetogenic such as chemotherapeutic agents, some antibiotics, bowel stimulants, opioids, NSAIDs.


  • Identify potentially reversible causes such as GER, gastroparesis, constipation, urinary retention, adynamic ileus, UTI.


  • Consider emotional and spiritual factors, including anticipatory anxiety related to medical treatments.


  • Initiate practical, non-pharmacologic interventions such as offering smaller, more frequent meals of blander food, relaxation techniques, appropriate body positioning while eating or when being fed orally or by PEG tube.


  • Prescribe pharmacologic treatment based on the major cause(s) of nausea/vomiting (refer to Table 3).

Combination pharmacotherapy based on each medication’s different antiemetic physiologic mechanism may be necessary especially if nausea/vomiting has multiple etiologies or is refractory. Dexamethasone, metoclopramide, and low-dose antipsychotics have central antiemetic effects.

Be aware of the likely side effects of serotonin receptor antagonists such as ondansetron (headache, constipation, fatigue, xerostomia), as well as anticholinergics and antihistamines (drowsiness, fatigue, confusion, dry mouth, constipation, urinary retention, blurred vision). Metoclopramide can induce EPS, dystonia and tardive dyskinesia. Low dose haloperidol (0.5–2 mg) or olanzapine (2.5–7.5 mg) may be useful in alleviating nausea/vomiting.

Dronabinol can have an antiemetic effect though poor evidence of efficacy (start at 2.5 mg twice a day to a maximum of 20 mg/day). Common adverse effects include somnolence, asthenia, paranoia, nausea, and vomiting. Opioid-induced nausea/vomiting may require either a dose reduction of the opioid or rotation to another opioid.


Constipation


Many patients who reside in a long term care setting experience constipation, especially if terminally ill. Constipation can occur because of a combination of poor fluid intake, low dietary fiber, impaired mobility and constipating drugs such as opioids, anticholinergics, iron, calcium preparations, and antihypertensives such as calcium channel blockers, diuretics, and clonidine.

Management of constipation includes the following:



  • Prevention is paramount.


  • Identify potentially reversible causes, including medication-induced and medical conditions such as a fecal impaction; metabolic disturbances (hypercalcemia, hypothyroidism); GI causes (especially be aware if obstruction is present); and neurologic causes (such as nerve root or spinal cord compression or visceral neuropathy that may occur in Parkinson’s disease).


  • Identify life-threatening causes such as a bowel obstruction or narcotic bowel syndrome.


  • Practical interventions include making toilets accessible, establishing a bowel routine, and encouraging increased fluid intake (if tolerated).


  • Reduce the anticholinergic medication load if possible.


  • Establish an individualized bowel regimen according to each laxative’s mechanism of action (refer to Table 4). Combination therapy is often required.


    Table 4
    Stepwise regimen to prevent or treat constipation “The Sixth Vital Sign”






































    1. Begin with:

    Senna with/without docusate

    1–2 tabs/cap qd-bid

    2. Titrate up to:

    Senna

    3–4 tabs bid

    3. If needed add:

    Sorbitol or lactulose

    30 cc qd-bid

    or
     

    Polyethylene glycol

    17 g in 8 oz water qd-bid

    4. Consider, in addition:

    Glycerin rectal suppository with/without bisacodyl rectal suppository

    Scheduled qd-qod

    5. If needed:

    Mineral oil or soapsuds enema
     

    6. If rectal impaction:

    May need digital disimpaction
     


  • Monitor for side effects of laxatives that can include bloating, cramping, nausea, and diarrhea.


  • Bulk-forming laxatives are usually not recommended because they can exacerbate constipation in underhydrated and less mobile patients and often cause or worsen bloating, nausea or vomiting.

Remember to prevent opioid-induced constipation: as the dose of the opioid is increased, so must the laxative regimen also be increased. Stimulant laxatives such as senna are most effective for opioid-induced constipation. In severe constipation, consider oral lubiprostone or methylnaltrexone sc, though they are expensive.

Stool softeners are considered to have poor effectiveness but can be initially prescribed in some patients when initiating their bowel regimen, i.e., the “laxative ladder ”. Remember that some patients may also require use of a rectally administered lubricating agent (glycerin) and/or stimulant (bisacodyl) to ensure adequate defecation in combination with oral agents. Noted that rectal fecal impaction can cause “paradoxical” diarrhea or urinary retention, either of which may not be evident. This often requires manual disimpaction, though a polyethylene glycol solution taken orally may be effective.


Delirium


Delirium is an acute confusional state that is characterized by a fluctuating course through the day/night, inattention, and disorganized thinking and speech. Delirium can be hyperactive, hypoactive, or mixed. A good caveat to remember is that any acute illness or any medication regardless of when it was started, can precipitate delirium especially in patients with advanced illness.

Management of delirium in patients with advanced, serious illness includes the following:



  • Identify potentially reversible causes, especially whether it may be medication-induced.


  • Discontinue nonessential medications and reduce anticholinergic load.


  • Initiate practical interventions: familiarize the patient to the environment, improve sleep and the sleep–wake cycle, reduce environmental stimuli, optimize hearing and eyesight (i.e., hearing aids “in,” eyeglasses “on”), and ensure adequate hydration.


  • Reduce immobility by removing/minimizing use of any physical restraints, including Foley catheters.


  • Determine whether pain could be contributing to the delirium, and if so, treat it appropriately.


  • If delirium persists consider first line medication therapy with low-dose haloperidol (no more than 2–3 mg/day), often in divided doses.


  • Second line medication may include a low-dose benzodiazepine, usually lorazepam 0.5–1 mg PO/SL every 6–8 h, more frequent if necessary; or valproic acid 125–250 mg every 12 h or upon awaking in the morning and at bedtime.

Remember that opioids and steroids can cause delirium. Both haloperidol and lorazepam can cause paradoxical agitation or restlessness in which case their dose should be decreased (not increased) or discontinued. It is not uncommon to use combination therapy with both haloperidol and lorazepam. Be aware that patients with dementia are more sensitive to the adverse effects of antipsychotic medications that include sedation and EPS, and that antipsychotics have also been associated with an increased risk of sudden death and cerebrovascular events. Communication with the patient and their family about these risks and benefits must occur. Overall, judicious medication management as well as social, environmental, and practical interventions must all be implemented in an attempt to prevent and treat delirium. For further information refer to the Chap. “Dementia, Delirium, and Depression,” which discusses delirium.



Pain Management


Effective pain management is essential to high quality palliative care in post-acute and LTC medicine. Given that there is a high prevalence of potentially pain-producing medical conditions in this patient population. The goals of pain control include:



  • Relieve pain


  • Relieve suffering


  • Prevent/minimize disability


  • Preserve decision-making capacity

It is necessary for practitioners to assess each patient for the presence of pain and for “total pain”; that is, the physical, psycho-emotional, social, and spiritual components of pain and how each can affect the other. Successful pain management entails evaluation and interventions that address each component of a patient’s total pain. As with any distressful symptom, pain is more optimally managed if its cause and pathophysiologic mechanisms can be determined. Using an interdisciplinary approach with multiple treatment modalities, including both nonpharmacologic and pharmacologic treatments, will also optimize pain management. The most recent AMDA Clinical Practice Guideline on pain management [9] and the AGS publication, Geriatrics at Your Fingertips [12] are excellent up-to-date resources that provide more in depth content than permits in this chapter. Also, the AGS guidelines on the pharmacologic management of persistent pain in older persons is another noteworthy resource [13].

Key components to the evaluation of pain include the following:

Jul 2, 2017 | Posted by in GERIATRICS | Comments Off on Palliative Care into Practice

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access