© Springer International Publishing 2017
Archie Bleyer, Ronald Barr, Lynn Ries, Jeremy Whelan and Andrea Ferrari (eds.)Cancer in Adolescents and Young AdultsPediatric Oncology10.1007/978-3-319-33679-4_3131. Palliative Care
Karen Wasilewski-Masker1 , Tracy Howk2 , Erin Connelly2 , Sergey Postovsky3 , Pamela Brill2 , Kate Carlson Wrammert4 and Rathi Pillai4
(1)
The Aflac Cancer & Blood Disorders Center at Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta, Emory University School of Medicine, 5455 Meridian Mark Road, Suite 400, Atlanta, GA 30342, USA
(2)
The Aflac Cancer & Blood Disorders Center at Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta, Atlanta, GA, USA
(3)
Department of Pediatric Hematology Oncology, Ruth Rappaport Children’s Hospital, Haifa, Israel
(4)
Department of Hematology and Medical Oncology, Winship Cancer Institute of Emory University, Atlanta, GA, USA
Abstract
Cancer is a leading cause of death in adolescents and young adults (AYAs) Wiener et al. (Pediatr Blood Cancer 60(5):715–718, 2013). Though most AYAs will survive, cancer will become incurable in 10–40 % Schrijvers and Meijnder (Cancer Treat Rev 33(7):616–621, 2007). Although the general philosophies of palliative care apply to AYAs, developmental considerations are unique to this group (Ferrari et al. J Clin Oncol Off J Am Soc Clin Oncol 28(32):4850–4857, 2010); Wein et al. J Clin Oncol Off J Am Soc Clin Oncol 28(32):4819–4824, 2010). The interaction of psychosocial, emotional, physical, and existential issues is essential to consider (Wein et al. J Clin Oncol Off J Am Soc Clin Oncol 28(32):4819–4824, 2010). The gaps in care experienced on both sides of the healthcare system between pediatric and adult medicine can be particularly impactful when delivering palliative care. The benefit of a multidisciplinary palliative care approach is widely appreciated as is the need to begin the process early in order to develop a trusting relationship (Wiener et al. Pediatr Blood Cancer 60(5):715–718, 2013; Baker et al. Pediatr Clin N Am 55(1):223–250, 2008; Ferris et al. J Clin Oncol Off J Am Soc Clin Oncol 27(18):3052–3058). Honest communication which supports autonomy is essential in discussions of their goals, worries, risks versus benefits of treatment, and advanced care planning (Clark and Fasciano Am J Hosp Palliat Care 32(1):101–111, 2015; Christenson et al. J Pediatr Health Care Off Publ Natl Assoc Pediatr Nurse Assoc Pract 24(5):286–291, 2010; Linebarger et al. Pediatr Clin N Am 61(4):785–796, 2014).
31.1 What Is Palliative Care?
The word “palliate” means to alleviate, to mitigate, or to make the effects of something less harsh or intense. Palliative care is a medical subspecialty that has arisen to care for patients with terminal illnesses which focuses on symptom control and psychosocial challenges of the patients and their families to alleviate suffering. The World Health Organization (WHO) defines palliative care as “an approach that improves the quality of life of patients and their families facing the problem associated with life-threatening illness, through the prevention and relief of suffering by means of early identification and impeccable assessment and treatment of pain and other problems, physical, psychosocial and spiritual” [2–4, 6, 8–10]. The Center to Advance Palliative Care (CAPC) describes palliative care as “see[ing] the person beyond the disease” and as being “provided by a team of palliative care doctors, nurses and other specialists who work together with a patient’s others doctors to provide an extra layer of support” [3–5, 7, 9–11]. This multidisciplinary approach to patient care addressing physical symptoms and psychological distress and helping to clarify the goals of care for the patient as well as supporting the patient’s family is the core of the palliative care mission. Patients can benefit from palliative care at any stage of a terminal diagnosis, not necessarily only when there are no remaining treatments for the underlying condition. These services assist in affirming life by supporting the patient and family’s goals including dignity throughout the course of their disease, dying process, and death [12].
31.2 The Palliative Care Team and Setting
Resources and availability of palliative care teams and services vary, as does the location of care. The gaps in care experienced on both sides of the healthcare system between pediatric and adult medicine throughout AYA oncology can be particularly impactful when delivering palliative care. It is well recognized that cultures differ between pediatric and medical oncology settings as do resources [13]. While pediatric care has been described as nurturing, family centered and often enriched with supportive care and centralized services, the availability of palliative care and multidisciplinary services can be more limited versus medical oncology. In addition, the family-centric pediatric approach can limit the autonomy needed by AYAs and offered within the adult-based system. Ideally adult and pediatric palliative care providers coordinate to provide care, especially for the younger or transitioning AYA. However, regardless of setting or resources, the benefit of a multidisciplinary palliative care approach is widely appreciated [1, 6, 7]. The team ideally includes nursing, medical staff (palliative medicine doctor, oncologist, advanced practice providers), social work, psychology, and spiritual support [5]. Other support team members such as music and art therapists and nutritionists are beneficial. In both the pediatric and adult settings, the inclusion of a child life specialist can be critical in communication and legacy building with the AYA patient or their children.
Though palliative care services can be delivered in multiple settings, most palliative care is currently administered in the hospital by a palliative care consultation team [14]. Many hospital intensive care units and oncology units, both adult and pediatric, now routinely integrate specialized palliative care to help with symptom management and addressing goals of care. When available, ambulatory palliative care clinics can also be integral in transitioning care for patients originally seen in the hospital and helping to support patients who are continuing treatment for their cancer despite a poor prognosis. And, as the home is often the preferred location for end-of-life care and death, the inpatient or outpatient palliative care team can also help transition care directly to the patients in their homes or nursing homes often through hospice [15, 16]. Regardless of the members of the team or the location of care, a palliative care team taking care of AYA patients should be familiar with the specific developmental needs of AYAs.
31.3 Developmental Considerations of AYAs
While the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) defines adolescence as ages 10–19 and young adulthood as ages 20–24 years, AYA oncology defines the age range as 15–39 years, a span of three decades [9]. Although the general philosophies of palliative care apply to AYAs, developmental considerations are unique to this group which is also experiencing a multitude of “normal” life transitions [4, 5]. However, the interaction of psychosocial, emotional, physical, and existential issues is consistent and essential to consider in all AYAs [5]. What is also consistent is an “adult” understanding of death which can seem in direct conflict to the feeling of immortality often portrayed [5]. In fact, an adult understanding of death is usually achieved by age 9 [9]. Understanding, nurturing, and encouraging the normal development of AYAs while also acknowledging the abnormality of death at this age is the unique challenge of caring for this population [17].
31.3.1 The Younger AYA
Normal adolescent development includes physical changes with completion of puberty and physical maturation as well as psychosocial development marked by becoming independent, developing self-confidence, and exploring identity. Cognitively, adolescents gain the ability to think logically and abstractly. They begin questioning more as they develop their own values and beliefs [2]. This can be one of the most difficult times to encounter illness, especially terminal cancer [3]. Cancer and its treatment can delay pubertal development in the younger to mid-adolescent and alter both the physical appearance (hair loss, obesity, disfigurement) and capabilities (fatigue, weakness, sexual function) [3, 18]. Normal psychosocial development is compromised by an increased dependence on parents and others, physical changes that can interfere with self-confidence and intimacy, identity as a patient, and social isolation [2, 8].
In spite of this departure from normality, younger AYAs often have amazing insight into their disease, including their own mortality, and opinions and wishes for how they want to spend their remaining time [3]. While the experience of cancer at a young age can delay developmental milestones, other milestones can be reached more quickly due to the cancer experience [5]. Whereas in young children, decisions about end-of-life care, including do-not-resuscitate orders and sedation, are largely left to the parents, and the legal age of competency in the United States is age 18, adolescents often have the emotional and cognitive capacity to make these decisions starting around age 14 [5, 9]. Because of this dichotomy between capacity and legal competency, decision-making can be even more complex for adolescents versus young adults [18]. Shared decision-making with adolescents which supports autonomy should include discussions of their therapeutic goals, worries, risks versus benefits of treatment, and advanced care planning with both considerations and interventions based on their developmental needs [2, 9]. These discussions must be rooted in honesty as the development of trust and rapport is essential in communication. Especially within the pediatric setting, it can often be difficult to avoid paternalism, but treating the young AYA as an equal and providing advice or assistance for them to make their own decisions enable independence, self-confidence, and a sense of self [14].
Though family is not to be ignored in the delivery of palliative care at any age, it is an even more essential element in the care of an adolescent versus older AYA. According to the AAP Guideline on Pediatric Palliative Care and Hospice Care, it is important for care to be patient centered but “…with a constant commitment to providing the best possible care for that child in a manner that fully engages, respects, and partners with the patient’s family.” This care should not only include partnering with the parents but supporting the siblings as well [19].
31.3.2 The Older AYA
Developmentally, transition from adolescence into adulthood is marked by an increased sense of self, awareness of others, development of meaningful relationships and family, an established sense of beliefs, and increasing adult responsibilities such as commitment to work and relationships, parenting, and even caring for one’s own parents [2]. Younger adults in their late teens to early 20s are normally experiencing personal and spiritual growth and exploration of the adult world, but as young adults mature into their late 20s and 30s, they are often more settled in work, relationships, and their own lives.
A diagnosis of terminal cancer interferes with completing education, finding or keeping work, career planning, and relationships and can lead to loss of recently gained employment and financial independence. And, although the legal aspects of decision-making are more straightforward in young adults versus adolescents, there are unique challenges including disclosure of illness in the work setting as well as in new relationships [2]. Focus on family is still developmentally important; but whereas in younger AYAs, the family often includes the parents and siblings, in older AYAs, the role and needs of young spouses and children must be considered. The foundation of communication with healthcare providers must still include honesty and the development of trust, as in younger AYAs.
31.4 Introducing Palliative Care
Introducing palliative care to the AYA population carries with it unique challenges, in an already-challenging specialty. In general, palliative care is an often-misunderstood service confused with end-of-life care, with this misconception more prevalent in pediatric versus adult medicine [20]. While palliative care focuses on the relief of symptoms caused by a terminal illness, it is more accurately “the art and science of lessening physical, psychological, emotional, and existential suffering” [21]. This is a daunting yet crucial understanding in introducing care to the AYA oncology patient.
The adult literature has demonstrated the benefit of introducing palliative care early in the course of diagnosis and treatment [22, 23]. Early introduction of these services can result in increased quality of life, decreased anxiety and depression, and decreased utilization of hospital resources and chemotherapy at the end of life, and patients may actually live longer [22]. In 2011 the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) published a provisional clinical opinion recommending that both standard oncology care and palliative care be considered early for “any patient with metastatic cancer and/or high symptom burden” [24]. While this may be applicable for older patients or within the field of medical oncology, within pediatric oncology, the presence of metastatic disease is not necessarily predictive of risk for morbidity or mortality. In the same year, the CAPC published consensus guidelines to help identify hospitalized patients who could benefit from palliative care [25]. The first step is identifying patients who have a life-limiting condition. Patients who have frequent admissions for the same condition, an admission for difficult-to-control symptoms, complex care needs at home, or a decline in function at admission should prompt a palliative care consultation. In addition, patients who have a prolonged intensive care unit stay, have a lack of clarity in goals of care, or have challenges with consensus with family or staff regarding treatment decisions including resuscitation preferences, use of non-oral feeding or hydration, or other major medical treatment decisions are likely to benefit from a palliative care consultation. Providers caring for patients who may undergo a tracheostomy, feeding tube placement, initiation of dialysis, and other device placements may consider a palliative care consultation to help patients and their families with decision-making.
The unique challenges of the AYA population in regard to introducing palliative care include their developmental stage, their physical differences from older adults, their psychosocial needs, and the need to care for their parental units, young spouses, and young children. However, within this span of these three decades (defined as ages 15–39), common threads of AYAs include a tremendous amount of life transition and that health, not morbidity and mortality, is the norm.
George suggests that the crux of the approach to the AYA must be rooted in autonomy and control for the AYA. He states: “ Whilst it may sit uncomfortably, when facing the truth that a young person is dying, there is a strong case to make that observing autonomy, even when it is clearly not in the best interest of the patient may be more important than the consequence of a shorter life” [17]. Clearly, in the AYA population that is less than 18 years of age, this can be confounded by parental rights. However, regardless of age, the AYA must have autonomy and some control when treatment and palliative decisions are made. So when introducing the concept of palliative care and its team, it is imperative to allow the AYA the space to make decisions regarding how he/she will spend the remaining time they have.
The key tool in introducing palliative care to the AYA is honest communication [8]. Providers need to balance being realistic and devoid of false hope with being positive and hopeful. This dichotomy is hard and certainly changes as the disease marches on. This can be accomplished by developing a relationship with the AYA early in treatment and cultivating trust throughout various stages of the illness. There is also tremendous therapeutic power in the willingness to sit in loving silence, as uncomfortable as that may be to providers who are used to discussing interventions and plans. Sometimes inaction is preferable to action – “Don’t just say something, stand there.” Let the patient and family talk about what they think the plan and intervention should be.
The parent role, especially for adolescents, must be considered carefully when introducing palliative care. Evidence shows that how a child dies is of critical importance in the parents’ further lives [26]. From the moment of diagnosis, there is bereavement; so, for the parent, palliative care starts at diagnosis. Throughout the illness trajectory, there are varied stages of bereavement: grieving what the young person is missing, grieving the loss of the family dynamic, and grieving the potential of life without their child. This is precisely why palliative care can be so helpful to the family from the time of diagnosis. If we refer back to the definition of palliative care as being the art and science of lessening suffering, then this is a desperate need families have as soon as their family member is diagnosed with a life-threatening illness.
Formal tools exist to aid in the introduction of palliative care. The Comfort Care Communication Tool (CCCT) was developed by the pediatric palliative care service at the Children’s Hospital and Regional Medical Center in Seattle [8]. It is designed to be introduced by a multidisciplinary team and includes a four-quadrant design to document medical issues, quality of life, contextual issues, and patient preferences. An additional tool, Voicing My CHOiCES™ can be used to initiate communication regarding end-of-life care and is further described later in this chapter [27] (See Sect. 31.5 “End-of-Life Care”).
When introducing palliative care to the AYA, it is imperative to begin the process early in order to develop a trusting relationship. It is equally imperative to allow the AYA to be as autonomous as possible with respect to decision-making. Finally, truth-telling and transparency are paramount and the building block for all future goals. The most negligent thing that can be done as providers is refuse to engage the reality of death or wait until the patient is at the end stage of illness. We need to do better. By working as a team, introducing palliative care early, and listening to AYAs with cancer, suffering can be ameliorated and true palliation provided throughout their disease course.
31.5 End-of-Life Care
Every year, more than 11,000 AYAs, 15–34 years of age, die from cancer and other life-threatening conditions [27]. Unfortunately due to provider discomfort with approaching end-of-life discussions, these conversations are often delayed in being initiated or avoided all together. Many healthcare providers feel uncomfortable, unprepared, and unskilled in having end-of-life discussions. AYAs can be perceived as not being competent to make such decisions, further adding to the exclusion in end-of-life planning [27]. Given the broad age range and developmental variability, end-of-life discussions present unique challenges because what is appropriate at one end of the continuum for an adolescent can be completely inappropriate for an adult in their 30s [27]. However, not approaching these topics risks contributing to emotional isolation during the dying process [28].
31.5.1 Advanced Care Planning
When to initiate end-of-life discussions is a critical moment for healthcare providers. As with the introduction of palliative care, most literature supports introducing end-of-life planning when the patient is clinically stable and not in crisis [1]. Waiting until a medical crisis occurs to initiate these discussions can leave the healthcare provider and family in the dark regarding the wishes of the AYA. Despite limited resources available to meet the unique needs of this population, two well-known documents exist to help AYAs with end-of-life planning: Five Wishes and Voicing My CHOiCES™. These documents are age-appropriate guides and can assist providers when initiating this difficult conversation. Five Wishes is an advance care document addressing comfort, future planning, spirituality, durable power of attorney, and life support options. This document served as the foundation for the most current resource for end-of-life planning, Voicing My CHOiCES™, which incorporated the feedback of AYAs.
“While always heartbreaking, the most intimate and peaceful adolescent deaths are those where the AYA trust their choices are respected, believe that they made a footprint on others’ lives, and are assured that they will be remembered” [1].
In 2008, Wiener et al. published a study assessing the value of using Five Wishes as a way to facilitate end-of-life discussions with AYAs [28]. The Five Wishes document is comprised of five sections addressing different aspects of the end-of-life process: person who will make healthcare decisions when they cannot, type of medical treatment they want or do not want, how comfortable they want to be, how they want to be treated, and what they want their loved ones to know. Of those surveyed, 95 % of AYAs reported that this document was helpful to them. They identified items concerning how they wanted to be remembered as more important than topics concerning specific medical decision-making. This same study also reported that avoiding the topic of end-of-life and dying created feelings of isolation, fear, and anxiety. Five Wishes is an advance directive that meets the legal requirements in most states, is appropriate for all adults, and is available in 26 different languages [29].
Voicing My CHOiCES™ became available in October 2012 and is specifically tailored to assist AYAs in end-of-life planning [28]. It uses developmentally appropriate language and detailed information and contains both open-ended and closed-choice questions. It addresses how the AYA wants to be treated, cared for, and supported during their illness and how they want to be remembered after death. This document can ensure that an AYA’s wishes of how they die are honored. There are nine sections: comfort, support, medical care decisions, medical treatment, family/friends to know, spiritual thoughts, remembrance, belongings, and voice (letters). Completing this document is a process. It requires multiple discussions at various time points throughout treatment. It is recommended that the AYA and healthcare provider complete the section regarding life support decisions together. Unlike the Five Wishes document, Voicing My CHOiCES™ is not a legally binding document. However, it provides direction to parents, caregivers, and healthcare providers regarding the AYA’s desires and wishes.
31.5.2 Location of End-of-Life Care
One of the important choices an AYA has is where to die. While in-home hospice and inpatient hospice services are widely available for adults in the United States, the availability of services in some areas for those under the age of 18 may be limited. While for AYAs with cancer, their parents, and providers, home is often the preferred location for end-of-life care and death, hospitals remain the most common place of death [14–16, 30]. Geographic location of services as well as diagnosis, symptoms, family, marital status, socioeconomics, and ethnicity may all play a role in where an AYA dies [15, 30, 31]. The location of death is not nearly as important as being given the choice and acknowledging that it is acceptable for that choice to change over time.
The challenge for healthcare providers is how to delicately balance being hopeful while also allowing for meaningful, honest conversations about death and choices. The likelihood of an ideal time to approach the subject is rare. However, not approaching these discussions and lack of communication can lead to emotional distance, leaving the AYA feeling alone, afraid, and without control during a critical time [28].
31.6 Symptom Management in End-of-Life Care
Palliative care provides comfort care for any individual who is experiencing a life-threatening illness from diagnosis to death [22, 32, 33]. Access to a multidisciplinary palliative care team is essential when managing the complex physical and emotional symptoms of AYAs living with cancer [1, 5–7]. These services assist in affirming life by supporting the patient and family’s goals including dignity throughout the course of their disease, dying process, and death [12]. The symptoms of cancer, its treatment, and its progression are determined by the cancer type and location as in any other age group. In younger AYAs, distressing physical symptoms have been reported in 89 % of patients receiving palliative care [3, 5]. Most patients experience multiple symptoms. The most common symptoms during palliative care are fatigue (57–86 %), decreased mobility and paralysis (76 %), pain (73 %), poor appetite (71 %), and dyspnea (6–21 %) [3, 5], though in the last week of life, dyspnea and pain may become more common [14].