Health Status, Work Productivity, and Costs Associated with Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy


References

Study type

Data source

Patient population

Sample size

Type of cost

Mean incremental cost

Mean total cost

Notes

Gordois et al. (2003) [7]

Cost-of-illness model

Prevalence and incidence rates from literature; unit costs from database and expert opinion

DPN

N/A

DPN

$1,975 (2001 US$)

N/A
 
Le et al. (2006) [8]

Retrospective database

Claims database

DPN (ICD-9: 205.6x)

2,146

AC

$19,946 (2003 US$)

$24,765 (2003)

Excludes patients with depression
     
D

$3,828 (2003 US$)

$5,125 (2003)

Excludes patients with depression

Boulanger et al. [9]

Retrospective database

Claims databases

DPN (ICD-9-CM: 250.6x and/or 357.2)

38,840

AC

N/A

$22,154 (2006)
      
D

N/A

$5,528 (2006)
 
Gore et al. (2011) [12]

Retrospective database

Claims database

DPN w/pregabalin or duloxetine

(ICD-9-CM: 250.6x and/or 357.2)

1,426

AC

N/A

$30,897
 
Gore et al. (2011) [11]

Retrospective database

Claims database

DPN w/pregabalin or gabapentin

(ICD-9-CM: 250.6x and/or 357.2)

2,356

AC

N/A

$32,258
 
Wu et al. (2011) [13]

Retrospective database

Claims database

DPN (ICD-9-CM: 250.6x and/or 357.2) w/ pregabalin, gabapentin, duloxetine, venlafaxine, or tricyclic antidepressants aged 18–64
 
AC

N/A

$30,951 (2007)

Excludes patients with depression
    
499

D

N/A

$9,223 (2007)

Excludes patients with depression


N/A not applicable, DPN diabetic peripheral neuropathy, AC all-cause, D diabetes-related. The weighted mean is presented for studies with multiple treatment groups



An analysis of a claims database comparing patients with neuropathy to those with diabetes provided a similar estimate of the diabetes-specific incremental cost of medical care (in 2003 dollars). Regression-adjusted mean annual cost of diabetes care of $5,125 among those with DPN compared with $1,297 for those with diabetes but without neuropathy or depression. Neuropathy patients also had higher rates of comorbidities, and greatly elevated all-cause healthcare costs. Those with neuropathy had approximately $25,000 in annual all-cause medical costs compared to approximately $5,000 for those with diabetes, with significantly higher costs in all types of care, including inpatient, outpatient, ER, and pharmacy costs [8]. Another study comparing DPN patients with depression and/or anxiety versus those without depression and anxiety across multiple claims databases found all-cause healthcare costs of approximately $22,000 per patient per year, with approximately $3,000 worth of diabetes-specific care (2006 US$).1 [9] The lower costs reported in this study are partially due to the inclusion of patients with Medicare supplemental insurance. Limiting analyses to commercially-insured patients would raise the diabetes-related and all-cause healthcare costs to approximately $3,900 and $24,900 per patient per year, respectively.

Much of the recent literature has focused on the costs associated with pDPN. Healthcare resource use is clearly elevated among those with DPN [10], and increased use begets increased costs. Several studies have compared costs between patients receiving different treatments for DPN pain. Though these comparisons are outside the scope of this review, the medical costs incurred by these patients are even higher than those reported for DPN in general. Those newly prescribed pregabalin or gabapentin for pDPN incurred approximately $32,000 worth of direct medical costs in the year following the index date [11]. A similar analysis comparing medical costs among those prescribed pregabalin or duloxetine found similar mean costs of approximately $31,000 in the year following the index date [12]. Likewise, the overall mean direct costs incurred by patients aged 18–64 with pDPN treated with either duloxetine or standard of care was approximately $31,000 [13].



Patient Reported Health Status and Functioning


Despite the large literature on the cost consequences of DPN, fewer studies have examined the health status of these patients. Most of these have focused on the health status among patients with pDPN, as non-painful DPN has a less perceptible impact on patient-reported outcomes [4]. Table 10.2 overviews the major studies which have investigated these issues.


Table 10.2
Summary of prior studies investigating the health status of patients with pDPN



































































































References

Sample

Measures

Mean level of health status

Currie et al. (2006) [16]

Patients with ICD-10 code of TD1 or TD2 (n  =  1,125)

QOL-DN

No pain: 25.84; Mild: 34.76Moderate: 40.83; Severe: 48.06
   
EQ-5D

No pain: 0.81; Mild: 0.63Moderate: 0.52; Severe: 0.25
   
SF-36 General Health Profile

No pain: 59.92; Mild: 41.78Moderate: 36.54; Severe: 25.54

DiBonaventura et al. [15]

Respondents from the 2006–2008 NHWS who reported T2D and pDPN (n  =  1,506)

SF-12 Physical component summary score

Mild: 47.74; Moderate: 43.36;Severe: 39.26
   
SF-12 Mental component summary score

Mild: 39.64; Moderate: 31.21;Severe: 26.06

DiBonaventura et al. (2011) [14]

Longitudinal respondents from the NHWS who self-reported pDPN (n  =  290), self-reported T2D but not pDPN (n  =  1,037), and did not self-reported T2D (n  =  8,162)

SF-8/SF-12 Physical component summary scorea

Non-diabetes control: 46.82; Non pDPN control: 46.07; pDPN: 41.58
   
SF-8/SF-12 Mental component summary scorea

Non-diabetes control: 50.43; Non pDPN control: 50.98; pDPN: 50.51

Gore et al. (2005) [31]

TD1 or TD2 patients with physician-diagnosed pDPN (n  =  255)

SF-12 Physical component summary score

Mild: 37.5; Moderate: 31.7Severe: 27.6
   
SF-12 Mental component summary score

Mild: 47.8; Moderate: 43.7; Severe: 39.1
   
EQ-5D

Mild: 0.70; Moderate: 0.50; Severe: 0.20

Benbow et al. (1998) [30]

TD1 or TD2 patients with pDPN (n  =  79) and non-diabetic controls (n  =  37)

VAS

pDPN: 48.5
   
NHP-Emotional reactions

Non-pDPN: 0.0; pDPN: 27.3
   
NHP-Energy

Non-pDPN: 24.0; pDPN: 63.2
   
NHP-Pain

Non-pDPN: 0.0; pDPN: 53.5
   
NHP-Physical mobility

Non-pDPN: 10.7; pDPN: 22.0
   
NHP-Social isolation

Non-pDPN: 12.6; pDPN: 0.0
   
NHP-Sleep

Non-pDPN: 0.0; pDPN: 50.4


TD1 type 1 diabetes, TD2 type 2 diabetes, pDPN painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy, NHWS National Health and Wellness Survey, QOL-DN Norfolk Quality of Life Questionnaire-Diabetic Neuropathy, SF Short Form, VAS visual analog scale, NHP Nottingham Health Profile

aAdjusted for demographic, health behavior, and comorbidity differences

DiBonaventura and colleagues [14] conducted a longitudinal assessment of those with pDPN over a 3-year period using the US National Health and Wellness Survey, a patient-reported database from a representative sample of adults in the USA [14]. Although the NHWS is cross-sectional in its design, a modest number of respondents complete multiple surveys (due to its sampling-with-replacement across years). As a result, patients with pDPN (n  =  290) were compared with patients with diabetes but without pDPN (n  =  1,037) and patients without diabetes (n  =  8,162). Controlling for various confounding variables such as demographics, health behaviors, and comorbidities, patients with pDPN reported significantly worse health status as assessed using the Short Form 12 (version 2) Health Survey instrument [14].

Particularly interesting, however, was the decline in health status observed over this 3-year period. The physical component summary scores of those with pDPN decreased at a significantly faster rate compared with the other groups [14]. This suggests that not only is pDPN associated with a decrement in physical health status but that the size of this decrement increases over time. One clear implication based on this result is the need for early intervention.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Apr 9, 2017 | Posted by in ENDOCRINOLOGY | Comments Off on Health Status, Work Productivity, and Costs Associated with Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access