Economic Impact of Prostate Cancer Bone Metastases


Skeletal-related event

Mean cost per skeletal-related event (€)

Germany

Italy

Spain

UK

Non-vertebral fracture

1,720

2,087

3,209

2254

Vertebral fracture

2,124

2,142

6,968

1,015

Radiation to bone

1,694

2,461

2,378

704

Spinal cord compression

5,,847

4,884

7,903

12,082

Surgery to bone

9,407

3,348

4,263

7,447



In the four countries considered, more than 83 % of costs were due to inpatient stay for spinal cord compression and bone surgery. For non-vertebral fractures in the UK and Spain, more than 88 % of costs were due to inpatient stays, while in Italy and Germany, this proportion was 79 % (19 % for procedures) and 64 % (28 % for procedures), respectively. For vertebral fractures in Italy and Spain, more than 94 % of costs were due to inpatient stays, while in Germany this category of cost covered 83 % of costs (14 % due to procedures) and in the UK 9 % were due to inpatient stays, 37 % to outpatient visits, and 53 % to procedures. The wider difference in terms of costs’ proportion among countries was observed also for radiation therapy: in Germany procedures covered 45 % of costs, followed by inpatient stays (42 %) and outpatient visits (13 %); in Italy 78 % of costs were due to procedures, followed by inpatient stays (17 %); in Spain the main cost category was inpatient stays (64 %) followed by outpatient visits (27 %) and procedures (9 %); and in the UK 50 % of costs were due to outpatient visits and 47 % to procedures.

The highest cost was associated with surgery to bone followed by spinal cord compression in Germany, with spinal cord compression followed by surgery to bone in Italy and the UK, and with spinal cord compression followed by vertebral fracture in Spain, confirming the high regional variability of procedures and cost.

Previous analysis, indeed, had been conducted on the population of single countries. In 2011, Félix et al. [14] conducted a multicenter, retrospective study to assess skeletal-related events’ costs in 152 patients with bone metastases in prostate (31 patients) and breast (121 patients) cancers in Portugal. Cost data were estimated according to the Portuguese National Health Service price list, considering activities provided by the hospitals involved in SRE identification and treatment. The estimated mean per capita costs related to skeletal events were 5,711 € (95 CI: 3,467 €–6,052 €) for patients with prostate cancer. In the prostate cancer group, the three main cost categories were hospitalization (38.7 %), medications (31.0 %), and radiotherapy (24.5 %). The mean cost per skeletal-related event in the whole sample is reported in the table below: the highest cost was associated with spinal cord compression, followed by pathologic fracture, hypercalcemia of malignancy, and radiotherapy.






















Skeletal-related event

Mean cost per event (€)

Spinal cord compression

13,203

Pathologic fracture

8,730

Hypercalcemia of malignancy

3,008

Radiotherapy

1,485

The year before, Pockett et al. [15] had published a similar article aimed at investigating the hospital burden of SREs associated with bone metastases in prostate cancer, breast cancer, and lung cancer in the Spanish population. Data related to 221 patients with prostate cancer, bone metastases, and SREs with hospital admissions between 2000 and 2006 were considered. The average cost for the first hospital admission of patients with skeletal-related events was 3,585 € (standard deviation: ± 1,538.8 €), while the cost of the first hospital admission of patients with prostate cancer metastatic bone disease but no SREs was equal to 3,180 € (standard deviation: ±2,081.9 €). The impact of SREs on total costs had been demonstrated since 2003 also in the Netherlands, where Groot et al. [16] evaluated the direct medical costs associated with bone metastases in 28 patients with prostate cancer and found a cost per patient equal to 13,051 €, of which 6,983 € were directly due to SREs (more than half of total direct medical costs).

An effort to overcome regional differences and to conduct a wider European analysis on the costs of bone metastases and SREs has been recently made by Pereira et al. [17], with a retrospective multinational study (Austria, the Czech Republic, Finland, Greece, Portugal, Sweden) that investigated the health resource utilization associated with skeletal-related events in patients with bone metastases secondary to prostate, breast, or lung cancer and multiple myeloma. The data sources were hospital charts of 356 patients with >19 years who experienced 744 skeletal-related events. The cost per event (in euros, referred to 2010), calculated assuming the National Health Service perspective, is reported in the table below.























































Skeletal-related event

Mean cost per skeletal-related event (€)
 
Austria

Czech Republic

Finland

Greece

Portugal

Sweden

Radiation to bone

14,603

2,258

7,251

9,734

5,144

3,270

Pathologic fracture

10,305

1,858

5,397

4,478

3,676

5,379

Spinal cord compression

22,191

6,140

14,447

7,538

5,739

13,000

Surgery to bone

21,496

6,030

13,343

7,943

7,130

10,666

The mean cost per event among the six countries considered was 7,043 € for radiation to bone, 5,242 € for pathologic fracture, 11,101 € for surgery to bone, and 11,509 € for spinal cord compression. This last event was the most onerous in Austria, the Czech Republic, Finland, and Sweden, followed by surgery to bone. In Greece radiation to bone resulted to be the event with more health resource consumption, followed by surgery to bone, while in Portugal surgery to bone was the most expensive procedure, followed by treatment of spinal cord compression.



20.2 Direct Health Costs of SREs in the USA and Canada


In the last years, several studies have investigated the economic impact of SREs also in the USA and Canada. Taking into account the different features of the health services between these countries and Europe, the results of the analyses were not so dissimilar to European ones since the difference essentially consists in the approach to the problem rather than in the problem itself (higher rate of hospitalization associated with SREs in Europe than in the USA, as well as longer hospital stay; higher rate of outpatient visits and procedures in the USA than in Europe) [18].

The cost of SREs in patients with prostate cancer and bone metastases was first investigated by Lage et al. [19], in a retrospective analysis on 342 patients (from year 2000 to 2005). The per capita mean cost for SRES was 12,469 US$, equally distributed among inpatient (48.7 %) and outpatient (51.3 %) activities. The mean costs per single skeletal-related event are presented in the table below.

























Skeletal-related event

Mean cost in US$ (95 % confidence interval)

Therapeutic radiology

5,930 (4,829–7,032)

Pathologic fracture

3,179 (1,745–4,614)

Bone surgery

2,218 (1,059–3,378)

Spinal cord compression

460 (116–803)

Other

681 (316–1,047)

The highest cost was associated with therapeutic radiology (radiation therapy), followed by pathologic fracture, bone surgery, and spinal cord compression.

A following analysis conducted by Barlev et al. [20] assessed the costs from the payer point of view of pathologic fractures, surgery to bone, and spinal cord compression in patients with bone metastases secondary to prostate cancer, breast cancer, or multiple myeloma (data from 2003 to 2009), considering subjects in Medicare and MarketScan databases with a hospitalization due to SREs. A total of 599 hospitalizations with skeletal-related events as primary diagnosis or procedure were identified for patients with prostate cancer with bone metastases: 130 cases of bone surgery (21.7 %), 416 bone fractures (69.4 %), and 53 spinal cord compressions (8.9 %). The mean payer costs for patients with prostate cancer are reported in the table below.



















Skeletal-related event

Mean cost in US$ (95 % confidence interval)

Surgery to the bone

42,094 (29,247–54,941)

Pathologic fracture

22,390 (28,417–37,067)

Spinal cord compression

59,788 (41,401–78,176)

A similar analysis was later conducted by Hagiwara and colleagues [21], in a retrospective observational study with data related to 1,237 patients with prostate cancer and bone metastases (from 2002 to 2011, data collected from the Thomson MedStat MarketScan Commercial Claims and Encounters database). Mean per capita costs due to hospital outpatient visits (7,471 US$, SD: ±14,837), physician office visits (5,826 US$, SD: ±11,515), hospitalizations (2,668 US$, SD: ±12,013), emergency department visits (334 US$, SD: ±1,601), lab visits (141 US$, SD: ±461), and home healthcare (119 US$, SD: ±790) were assessed. The costs per SRE were considered both in the inpatient and outpatient settings, as reported in the table below.









Skeletal-related episode

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 25, 2017 | Posted by in ONCOLOGY | Comments Off on Economic Impact of Prostate Cancer Bone Metastases

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access