Counseling LGBT Elders


Cognitive behavior therapy

Person-centered therapy

Existential therapy

Anger

Self-esteem issues

Anxiety

Depression

Guilt

Guilt and shame

Anxiety

Grief and loss issues

Loss and suffering

Life transitions

Relationship issues

Value clarification

Social anxiety

Growth work

Meaning

Caregiver distress

Insecurity

Mortality

Addictions

Aging

Life choices

Relationship issues

Coming out issues

Life transitions

Aging

Stress

Coming out issues



It should be noted that cognitive behavior therapy, person-centered therapy, and existential therapy were discussed in this chapter as approaches the authors thought would fit well with issues LGBT elders might face along with compatibility with a gay affirmative approach. There is no research to support that these specific therapeutic approaches might work better than other therapeutic modalities. Other psychotherapeutic approaches such as psychodynamic therapy, gestalt therapy, interpersonal therapy, and behavioral therapy may also be effective when combined with a gay affirmative approach when working with LGBT elders. Clinicians should always use their clinical judgment when selecting a treatment modality and planning psychotherapeutic interventions.


Discussion Box. 32.1

LGBT Dating for Older Adults

It would not be uncommon for LGBT elders to discuss issues of dating in their counseling sessions. Consider the following unique situations that a clinician might face when working with an LGBT Elder:



  • A lesbian presents for counseling after losing her wife of 31 years. Having resolved her grieving, the patient now inquires about how to meet someone new.


  • A 65-year-old gay man who had been married to a woman has recently “come out” and is wanting to begin dating men. He is seeking advice on the best way to meet other single gay men.


  • A bisexual woman has just ended her relationship with a man. She expresses a desire to start dating women. She does not want to go to bars or to religious-sponsored events and is perplexed about how best to find other bisexual women or lesbians.


  • A 58-year-old male to female (MTF) transgendered client has recently completed sexual reassignment surgery. She is seeking to begin dating for the first time as a female. She is concerned about whether to disclose being transgender with new dating partners.

How would you deal with each of the above situations in a counseling session? Remember, your role as a therapist is not to offer advice but to support the client in resolving their issues.




Other Counseling Modalities


While individual psychotherapy may be beneficial for many LGBT elders, other treatment modalities may also be effective for certain issues. The next section discusses how group counseling, couple’s counseling, and pastoral counseling may be helpful to certain LGBT elders.


Group Counseling


Group counseling is another form of psychotherapy that can be advantageous for LGBT elders (Ross et al. 2007). Group counseling offers different opportunities for individuals that are not available in individual counseling sessions. Some unique features of this modality are a therapy environment that replicates real-world situations, an opportunity to practice interpersonal skills, real-time feedback from peers, and social support (Yalom and Leszcz 2005). In the group setting, individuals are able to have their issues normalized by meeting with others who share similar issues or problems. This commonality allows them to not only work on their own specific issues, but to help others with their problems as well.

Frost (1997) notes that group psychotherapy can be advantageous for senior gay males, primarily because the format itself forces them to address a number of significant issues. Because typically in groups, there is an agreement to “stay until the work is done” (p. 275), members are forced to stay and deal with their interpersonal anxiety rather than leaving a stressful situation. He also notes that group psychotherapy may provide a way for gay men to increase their sense of self-worth by practicing new ways to relate positively to other men. For many group members who struggle with intimacy and vulnerability, the group dynamic provides a way to build a healthy sense of trust and connection with other group members (Ritter and Terndrup 2002).


Couples Counseling


Same-sex couples seek counseling for issues similar to those affecting all couples. Communication problems, infidelity and affairs, substance abuse, and decision-making about staying together or separating are issues faced by all clients (Cabaj and Klinger 1996). Besides these common issues, however, LGBT couples have unique issues that impact their relationships. According to Green (2004), most same-sex couples face similar issues, including (1) coping with societal homophobia and heterosexism; (2) defining a relationship despite the lack of a societal or legal model for same-sex relationships; (3) creating social networks that provide emotional support and establishing families of choice; and (4) maintaining flexible gender roles (thus avoiding over-dependency in female couples or emotional disengagement and competition in male couples).

Additional issues that may face same-sex couples are coming out issues. Stages of coming out may differ for each person in the relationship thus creating tension for the couple as to how “out” they are to other people. In other words, if one member is out to family and friends and the other is not, this may create tension in the relationship. Additionally, family dynamics may cause problems for same-sex couples. If the families of origin are not supportive, same-sex couples may have to negotiate discrimination not only from society, but also from their families. Being in a relationship that is not validated by one’s family can add to sexual minority stress (Connolly 2004).

With the legalization of same-sex marriage, some same-sex couples may be facing adjustment issues surrounding their newly defined relationships. While in the past they may have had to downplay or disguise their relationship, they are now able to openly share their relationship publicly. This may cause some issues of adjustment for the couple. Couples counseling may include ways to adjust to this new dynamic (Segal and Novack 2008).


Pastoral Counseling


Many older LGBT people may have felt oppressed by and now subsequently feel alienated from the religious traditions into which they were born (i.e., their spiritual traditions of origin). This may be especially true of those whose religious traditions are highly rigid or fundamentalist (Blando 2009). However, for some LGBT elders, organized religion and spirituality have been and continue to be a source of comfort and support (Halkitis et al. 2009; Rostosky et al. 2012) especially if the religious organization to which they belong is seen as gay-affirming (Sowe et al. 2014). If a client presents in counseling with issues surrounding religion and spirituality, it would be germane for the clinician to address those issues as thoroughly as possible within the scope of their training. At times, it may be best to refer the client for pastoral counseling if the issues fall beyond what the clinicians feel they are able to provide. Pastoral counseling may be provided by individuals specifically trained in religious counseling techniques. While each counseling situation is unique, pastoral counseling might be indicated for LGBT elders with strongly self-identified religious backgrounds, individuals having a type of religious crisis, or those contemplating existential or end-of-life issues (Halkitis et al. 2009). Clinicians should be sure to discuss pastoral counseling with the client before making a referral to be sure they both agree that it is therapeutically appropriate.


Summary


Although little empirical information exists on what constitutes effective psychotherapy for LGBT elders, positive strides have been made in moving from treatment focused on reparative or conversion-type therapies to gay affirmative treatment. LGBT elders as a specific population have certain unique issues that should be considered by clinicians when providing psychotherapy and counseling. While not all issues pertain to every individual, concerns about coming out, internalized oppression, sexual minority stress, and stereotyping are issues that should be considered by clinicians when counseling LGBT elders. Having an understanding of these issues promotes culturally competent practice.

Using a gay affirmative approach in counseling allows the clinician to combine different theoretical psychotherapeutic approaches when working with LGBT elders. Cognitive-behavioral therapy, person-centered therapy, and existential therapy lend themselves to effective counseling strategies when combined with a gay affirmative approach. Other theoretical approaches may also be equally effective with LGBT elders. Besides individual counseling, LGBT elders may benefit from group therapy, couples counseling, or pastoral counseling if indicated.



Learning Exercises


Explore the Services and Advocacy for Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Transgender Elders (SAGE) Web site at http://​sageusa.​org/​. Read one article or select a topic from the Web site that you feel would help your understanding of counseling LGBT seniors .


Self-check Questions




1.

Define cultural competence and how it relates to LGBT elders.

 

2.

According to the authors, what are the unique issues faced when counseling LGBT elders? Can you think of other issues that you may encounter when working with this population?

 

3.

Why is it important to understand the different stages of coming out? Are these stages different for LGBT seniors than younger adults?

 

4.

Discuss the differences between being culturally competent and stereotyping clients when working with LGBT elders.

 

5.

Do you feel that sexual minority stress is less for LGBT elders than younger adults? Why or why not?

 

6.

Some might argue that using a gay affirmative approach is appropriate for use with all clients. What do you think this means?

 

7.

How might a therapist use existential therapy when working with a client dealing with internalized oppression?

 


Multiple-Choice Questions




1.

Cultural competence can be defined as:

A.

Responding respectfully to people of all cultures, languages, classes, and races

 

B.

Affirming the values and the worth of individuals, families, and communities

 

C.

Protecting and preserving the dignity of diversity factors

 

D.

All of the above

 

 

Jun 5, 2017 | Posted by in GERIATRICS | Comments Off on Counseling LGBT Elders

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access