Case study 83.3
How to Choose Appropriate Systemic Therapy for the Patient with Newly Diagnosed Metastatic Disease
Two years after lumpectomy and radiation therapy for a T1N1M0 ER-positive, PR-positive, and Her2-negative cancer of the left breast, a 45-year-old woman presented with abdominal bloating. Following her original surgery she had declined adjuvant chemotherapy and endocrine therapy, but received postlumpectomy radiation. She is known to be BRCA negative.
CT scan showed numerous liver lesions. Remainder of metastatic evaluation was negative. Biopsy of liver confirmed the clinical diagnosis of metastatic ER-positive breast cancer.
1. Which would be the best choice of treatment for this patient? (Choose all that apply.)
- Endocrine therapy
- Single-agent chemotherapy
- Combination chemotherapy
- Entry on a clinical trial
The goals of treatment for a patient with metastatic disease are to provide palliation, improve quality of life, and prolong survival.
Treatment options include combination and sequential single-agent chemotherapy. Additionally, in patients with ER-positive disease, there are numerous options for endocrine therapy, and there are also now available several drugs that target the Her2 pathway in patients with Her2-positive disease.
What factors help the oncologist decide which treatment is most appropriate? Broadly speaking, the most important factors are the biology of the tumor and relevant prognostic factors, which include disease-free interval, sites of metastatic disease (visceral vs. nonvisceral sites), prior (adjuvant) systemic therapy, and extent of organ dysfunction and comorbidities.
Endocrine Therapy versus Chemotherapy
In general, endocrine therapy is usually the first option for most women with metastatic ER-positive disease. Endocrine therapy, designed to minimize estrogen stimulation of the tumor, is less toxic than chemotherapy and often produces responses of long duration.
This patient has received no prior therapy, and has a high probability of response to whatever drug treatment is used. She does have numerous liver lesions, however, and this represents a life-threatening clinical scenario. Median duration of survival for the patient with liver metastases who does not achieve clinical remission is generally less than 12 months. Endocrine therapy would therefore not be recommended as initial treatment here.
Single-Agent Chemotherapy versus Combination Chemotherapy
In general, combination chemotherapy produces higher overall response rates, longer time to progression, and longer overall survival when compared with single-agent chemotherapy, at a cost of higher toxicity.
Sequential single-agent chemotherapy is generally used in patients with less dire clinical scenarios, where there may be a longer disease-free interval from initial treatment until first recurrence, a lesser body burden of metastatic disease, and an absence of disease in dire visceral sites (liver, lymphangitic lung, and CNS).
This patient has several poor prognostic factors, which include the relatively short disease-free interval and, most importantly, the presence of numerous liver metastases, which are symptomatic.
In such a clinical scenario, the use of aggressive combination chemotherapy would be most appropriate. Given the fact that she is chemotherapy naïve, there is a high probability (approximately 60%) that combination chemotherapy would achieve a partial remission with a relatively low probability of complete remission (approximately 20%).
Most patients can expect relief of symptoms from shrinkage of the liver metastases. In general, remissions from any one treatment regimen tend to be of relatively short duration (median length approximately 9 months). Second remissions from subsequent treatment are common, however.
There are a large number of agents active against metastatic breast cancer. Most physicians would choose first-line treatment with an anthracycline- or taxane-containing regimen, which have shown an overall survival benefit in randomized studies.
The patient may be offered entry on an appropriate clinical trial if one is available.
< div class='tao-gold-member'>